5 sisters. 5 women. So similar. So different. Sharing their experiences with the world.
Three Pack
In the Hole
Alive and Well He Is
Five Kids and Counting
I admit at the outset of this blog that I am not a fan of “19 Kids and Counting.” Even before the most recent scandal involving Josh Duggar, I silently implored the public would stop encouraging, promoting and condoning what I perceived to be a grotesque exploitation of the family for financial gain. It is unfortunate it took a serious situation like Josh Duggar’s sexual exploitation of five children (four of whom were his sisters) to stop the show from being aired. It is even more unimaginable to me that large factions of the public are defending someone who is an unequivocal sexual predator and that TLC has not yet canceled the show outright. I understand, to some degree, the general resistance to labeling someone who does not openly engage in sexually deviant acts a predator. However, the reality is that all predators understand the importance of camouflage and very few predators show us what lies beneath an often unthreatening exterior.
Sexual predators camouflage themselves amongst the general population by being likeable and clean cut. They train themselves to say the right things. They prey on victims who are young, crazy, insecure and not credible. They find a way to minimize their conduct and convince others of the same. As a society, we are somewhat complicit in the sense that most people do not want to accept there are sexual deviants walking among us. It is much easier for the human psyche to believe a predator cannot hide in plain sight. Predators who are caught are not the ones who should scare us. Rather, we should be fearful of those predators who are never caught or if they are caught, their conduct is minimized to such an extent they are not labeled for what they really are, like Josh Duggar.
Jim Bob Duggar engaged in text book minimization during his defense of his son to Fox News correspondent Megyn Kelly. Jim Bob stated “Again this was not rape or anything like that, it was touching someone over the clothes. There were a couple times he touched someone under the clothes, for a few seconds. Each time he told us crying. It was the third time that we decided we needed help.” These three sentences clearly and effectively serve to minimize the seriousness of Josh Duggar’s criminal conduct. For example, Jim Bob first tells us that it was not rape. Technically, this is accurate as the conduct is more properly characterized in legal parlance as abusive sexual contact or sexual assault. However, the fact Josh did not commit a more serious crime does not somehow negate the fact that a different crime was committed. It is a difference in degree only. Outside the context of a sex crime, the illogical nature of this statement becomes apparent. For example, if a victim was beaten severely, it would make little sense to defend the acts of the perpetrator on the grounds that at least it was not murder.
Similarly, Jim Bob goes on to state the touching lasted for just a few seconds suggesting that a short crime is less serious than a longer one. Again, applied outside the context of sex crimes, the logical fallacy of this statement is readily apparent. For example, if a person committed armed robbery, it is not persuasive to argue that the robbery wasn’t as serious because it “only lasted a few seconds.” The reality is that a robbery victim is harmed by the intrusion and invasion, regardless of the amount of time the robbery actually lasts. No one can legitimately claim that a short robbery is somehow less serious than a long robbery.
Next, Jim Bob appears to suggest that remorse begets reformation by indicating his son cried about his actions. Once again, while this may be a nice sound bite, it is simply unsupported by the evidence. In most sentencing hearings I have participated in, the defendant apologizes, laments, cries and begs for forgiveness. However, once released from incarceration, many defendants go on to commit similar or worse crimes. The recidivism rate is well-documented within the justice system. Tears and apologies simply do not equate to reformation.
Finally, Jim Bob goes on to state that it took three separate occasions for the Duggars to decide they needed help. This is incredulous. If a child reported a teacher touched him or her inappropriately, no one would argue that perhaps the family should wait to see if happens a second time, much less a third time. If a child was punched by another student, the argument would not be made that action should not be taken until the child is hurt two more times.
In the same interview, Michelle claimed the girls were victimized more by the media blitz than what happened 12 years ago. She pointed out that the inappropriate touching occurred while the girls were asleep. Michelle clearly doesn’t understand the ramifications of non-consensual sexual contact. Having sex with someone who is incapable of providing consent does not mitigate against the seriousness of the conduct. Rather, it is actually worse because the perpetrator intentionally, willfully and knowingly took advantage of the person’s incapacitated state. Michelle clearly doesn’t understand that her and her husband’s failure to protect their children from harm is a much worse betrayal than a media story.
The Duggars’ current strategy, most likely in the hopes of getting their cash cow back on TLC, is to blame the media for re-victimizing their daughters. Twelve years ago, Michelle and Jim Bob chose to place their children in harm’s way by not accepting the seriousness of Josh’s criminal abuse of their daughters. Michelle and Jim Bob continued to place their children in harm’s way by forcing their children to grow up in the public eye in exchange for financial gain. Today, Michelle and Jim Bob continue to place their children in harm’s way by minimizing Josh’s conduct. The only people who have re-victimized their daughters are Jim Bob and Michelle. Perhaps they are the real predators here.
A Little Bit of Fit
Fitness trackers are saturating the market, and consumers are eagerly purchasing their wares.
Let me explain. I DO
love physical activity. I personally engage in walking, running, biking,
volleyball, strength training, and aerial silks. Moreover, I strongly advocate
that other people should engage in physical activity. Not only is it
advantageous for our physical health, but it is beneficial for our emotional
and spiritual health as well. I believe that our contemporary culture is far
too “heady” and that we become more grounded and connected when we engage
physically.So…there’s a part of me that wants a fitness tracker. Even though I’m already pretty active, I know that I can do better at driving my car less. I know that it would probably be beneficial to take more breaks during the workday to stretch and walk around. I would like to continue to maintain a steady weight. And…I’m gonna be honest…there’s a part of me that’s simply fascinated by the fact that fitness trackers exist, and that makes me want one. (Yes, the influence of American consumerism is certainly alive and well!)
| Numbers, numbers, and more numbers |
Is it possible? How do we promote healthy activity engagement ? What do you think?
CELEBRATE!
Speechless
It isn't often that I'm speechless and yet, today I find myself in such a state. I'm absolutely and utterly exhausted and simply lack the ability to dedicate my heart and soul to a post like I normally would. You see, all of the Alesch's-the assholes and the angels alike - and even a few of their friends and extended family descended upon St. John for middle sister Molly's wedding to a wonderful man named Lawrence. I spent a week in an alcohol - induced haze that seemed to be fueled by my very presence in paradise despite the activity of the day. Going boating? Grab the Corona. Going to the beach? Grab the rum. Going to Skinny Legs for a cheeseburger in paradise? Order the guava special. Have to give a toast at the wedding? Down five glasses of champagne. It was a fun, relaxing, beautiful, romantic and love filled week.
It was not without harsh words and included a bit of drama but that is to be expected when you have 13 adults and my two children crammed into a five bedroom villa. It was also not easy to get 13 people to do anything much less to do it on time. Plus, St. John is an expensive place to travel to, to stay and to play. Oh, and good luck getting cell phone service there. So there were worries about money, worries about getting in touch with others, worries about who paid for what and how much and worries about who got stuck with the couch. I was constantly worried about my kids and whether I made the right call in taking them with us. They were exposed to cursing, drinking and sarcasm. But they were also exposed to real life, real love, real forgiveness, the ocean, the island life and so much more. In the end, I know I made the right call. My children have not been sheltered from the bad but they have also witnessed first hand the good, the beauty. They see the give and take in relationships. They see that an argument doesn't mean you cease caring about a loved one. They see conflict resolution and that no one is perfect. They see that right and wrong can be fluid depending on the situation. They see that life is meant to be enjoyed and lived to the fullest. They also see that there is a big world out there and hopefully, someday will understand that the sun does not rise and set on them, the local sports team, the local competition, or their job. I'm not downplaying the benefit of doing one's best and participation in activities or work, but what I am against is the rabid and often parent dictated importance placed on things that truly do not matter. We owe it to our children to expand their spheres of reality, not limit their focus to myopic levels of self accomplishments.
We all returned to general chaos...Amy stranded in Texas for what seemed like an absolutely ridiculous amount of time due to weather and flight attendants not showing up for work, Kristen taking a final the next day, me driving all night to start military school, and John losing a bag that never made it out of St. Thomas. My son had to go to school the next day after going to bed at 11 p.m. Anne was the only semi-smart one of the group who took the next day off work.
But...none of that mattered. I would do it all again in a heartbeat in order to see any one of us get married by Anne with the rest of her sisters standing up as bridesmaids. Yes, I could have bitched. Yes, I could have made people pay me to the penny. Yes, i could have let someone else plan a boat day. Yes, my kids got sunburnt and so did I. But all of these things simply didnt matter to me. What mattered was that everywhere I looked, there was love. Love between Molly and Lawrence that simply emanated between them...love between five different sisters, love between two families, love between friends, and love between my kids and their extended families. Sure, this is probably present in any wedding but the fact that we had all traveled so far to share in this experience really made me see so clearly what a lovely gift Molly gave us in giving us the reason to travel as family and friends, and to enjoy a week in paradise--a gift that most of us would have never bothered to give ourselves unless we were made to. So Molly got married, and yet, I was the one who felt like the richest person in the world. It made think that is really funny how that works. The more we give, the more we receive. The more we refuse to accept a mentality of scarcity, the more we get back. And the more we embrace all of our emotions, the less power negative emotions hold over us because we begin to see they are just a small part of the whole. Whatever I spent in money, gained in pounds, and lost in liver functionality, I do not regret a single moment we were there in all of our dysfunctional yet beautiful glory. That's how an Alesch rolls.
Featured Post
Meaning-Making
I’m almost 38 years old. Here’s what I’ve learned and experienced about life as I age. The older I get, the more intensely I feel things. ...
-
Women, I want us to stop giving our power to men. I had a completely different post in mind for the past week and my rage about this topic h...
-
The world, myself included, was shocked by Robin Williams' suicide. News reports revealed he had privately struggled with depression and...
-
Seriously.... UGLY . I recently painted my entire apartment. Living room, dining room, hallway, and kitchen. I pain...




