Fit Bit. Jawbone. Garmin. iWatch. Misfit Shine.
Fitness
trackers are saturating the market, and consumers are eagerly purchasing their
wares.
I have a confession. Part of me wants a fitness tracker, and
another part of me loathes the very idea that they exist.
Let me explain.
I DO
love physical activity. I personally engage in walking, running, biking,
volleyball, strength training, and aerial silks. Moreover, I strongly advocate
that other people should engage in physical activity. Not only is it
advantageous for our physical health, but it is beneficial for our emotional
and spiritual health as well. I believe that our contemporary culture is far
too “heady” and that we become more grounded and connected when we engage
physically.
I’m also aware that our current cultural arrangements make
it easy to be sedentary. We sit at desks all day for our job. We work many
hours so we don’t have time to be physical. We have cars that take us exactly
where we need to go. We are inundated
with technology that mesmerizes us for hours at a time- Netflix, X-Box, Smart
phones, iPads, etc.
Fitness trackers, therefore, encourage us to be physical.
They remind us that we need to find
breaks to walk around when sitting at our desks. They persuade us that we do
not need to always drive to arrive at our location. They inspire us to work out
daily when we would rather go home and watch TV. And they encourage us to stop
consuming more calories than we burn.
So…there’s a part of me that wants a fitness tracker. Even
though I’m already pretty active, I know that I can do better at driving my car
less. I know that it would probably be beneficial to take more breaks during
the workday to stretch and walk around. I would like to continue to maintain a
steady weight. And…I’m gonna be honest…there’s a part of me that’s simply
fascinated by the fact that fitness trackers exist, and that makes me want one.
(Yes, the influence of American consumerism is certainly alive and well!)
However. (There is always, always a however! J ) There is also a part
of me (and right now this is the larger part) that does not want anything to do
with a fitness tracker.
Overall, I worry that fitness trackers and their numbers
cultivate unhealthy obsessions. Should we work on being more physical? You bet
we should. However, by quantifying our physicality, I’m worried that we stop
enjoying activities for what they are,
and we become more concerned with the final number that the activity will produce. Instead of enjoying a walk
with a friend, for example, we start to think about how many steps it will add
to our daily report.
|
Numbers, numbers, and more numbers |
Moreover, I’m also concerned about the pressure we place on
ourselves to reach a goal, and the potential guilt/shame that ensues if we do
not reach it. Perhaps we simply had a lazy Sunday in which we just wanted to
rest and binge watch Netflix. And we ordered pizza to boot. Because of our
obsession with numbers, I’m worried of the guilty feelings that this might
promote. Obviously, a day like that
would not yield the desired numbers, and I’m concerned that feelings of remorse
will stop us from enjoying the simple pleasure of a lazy day. While I don’t
think that we should have lazy days every day, I DO think that an occasional
one is actually quite constructive.
Finally, I am also concerned about the “end goals” that are
pushing us to track our fitness. I think that fitness trackers are often used
primarily as a means of losing weight. And I am simply exasperated with “losing weight” as a goal due to its narrow,
one-dimensional, superficial focus.
I want people to engage physically because they enjoy it. I
want people to engage physically because they want to increase their strength
and endurance. I want people to engage physically because it’s simply a
habitual part of their life.
I don’t want people to engage physically because of the
number they see on their screen at the end of the day.
Is it possible? How do we promote healthy activity engagement ? What do you think?