No, Meghan Trainor. It IS NOT "All About That Bass".

Women, I want us to stop giving our power to men. I had a completely different post in mind for the past week and my rage about this topic had me succumb and submit this altogether alternative, albeit timely, post instead. If you read no farther, take that first sentence, think about it and how it applies to your life and our society. If you're a man, read it and think about how it applies to every woman you care about, your life and our society.

No, Meghan Trainor...it IS NOT ALL ABOUT THAT BASS. The first time I heard this song, rage was sparked inside of me (and not just because it's a canned pop song, though, trust me, that added to it). In case you're unfamiliar, here are some of the lyrics:

"Yeah, it's pretty clear, I ain't no size two
But I can shake it, shake it
Like I'm supposed to do
'Cause I got that boom boom that all the boys chase
And all the right junk in all the right places."

And, to add insult to injury:

"Yeah, my mama she told me don't worry about your size
She says, 'Boys like a little more booty to hold at night.'

First of all, I must have missed the girl/woman memo that mentioned that we're "supposed to" "shake it". Now, I'm not naive-I know what this means and, to maintain my integrity and honesty, I have "shaken it" like I was "supposed to do". The fact that I, as a woman in my early 20s, knew what that meant (and let's be honest...that was almost 20 years ago, folks...girls younger than 10 know what it means in 2014), is evidence of a powerful societal norm and expectation in the United States. Why is a woman supposed to shake it? Answer: to attract men. A woman is not supposed to be intelligent or speak her mind or be her authentic self...she is supposed to shake it with her main goal the ever coveted "male attention". So what we have here, in one song lyric, is the message that our goal as women should be to attract a man. Again, NOT to be successful on our own terms, to be an individual, whatever that might look like, to love our selves, to strive for authenticity and inner beauty, male attention be damned...as women, we are told these beautiful goals are subservient to that goal of getting a man.

What makes this song even more heinous is that it has somehow been coronated as an anthem for women's self esteem and acceptance of all women's bodies as beautiful. While I agree with the sentiment and wish that all humans possessed self love for their physical, emotional and spiritual selves, this song says nothing of the sort. This song is an example of the innocuous drivel that tells our girls and women their bodies are beautiful, they are okay, ONLY IN RELATION TO MALE WANTS AND DESIRES. At least in the 1950s, it was in your face and could therefore be recognized and disputed outright. This song has millions of young girls fooled into thinking they are liberated and free from societal, mass media driven images of the perfect female body. Sorry to burst your bubble...nowhere in this song does it say that women are beautiful and amazing and powerful and compassionate and intelligent and love in their own right. The only reason, according to this song, that we don't have to worry about our size is IN RELATION TO MALE WANTS AND DESIRES. Gosh, Meghan Trainor...where would we be if boys didn't "like a little more booty to hold"? Back to square, or should I say size, one, I guess.

As a woman who succumbed to this message in her 20s and, as a result, stifled the amazing, beautiful woman who was actually inside of her, I am enraged to the point of shaking when I hear song lyrics and see messages like this. I'm sick and tired of women giving our power to men. We are good and beautiful and amazing whether men find us that way or not...because WE ARE. If that means we never "get a man" because an unenlightened man in our society can't handle us, fuck it. That should be the message we are sending our girls, our young women, our selves. I want someone to write a song about that.

The other deplorable part about all of this is that we don't only give our power over to men on behalf of our physical selves. We do it with our intellect, our creativity, our way of being in the world. We change our selves so we can be successful "in a man's world". We learn to take on traits valued by men so that we will be valued in the world they have created...and yes, in the United States, men have created the political, corporate, religious, academic and agricultural reality we currently live in. Do not doubt that. To succeed in these male created, male dominated systems, women are often forced to abandon feminine traits, their feminine selves. I've witnessed women do it...it kills our souls. The other alternative is to self select occupations and regions and cultures that value female characteristics and ways of being. Shockingly (insert sarcasm here), in the US, these are frequently niche areas such as sustainable agriculture or underpaid occupations such as teaching or social work. At what point are we going to address and be vocal about the real issue? The issue that the system was created BY MEN, FOR MEN, which makes it comparatively easy for men to succeed and most women destined to fail or fail themselves.

Am I happy that women have become CEOs and US Senators? Of course I am. What I am unhappy with is the systemic male bias our society's political, corporate, academic (which is getting pretty close to corporate these days) and religious entities are built on and the seeming unwillingness for these things to be addressed, even by women. Maybe women are too busy shaking it like we're supposed to. Or maybe women have eaten the poison pill surrounded by red velvet cake that is being shoved down our throats with songs like "All About That Bass". Until women are taught to value self beyond our
relationship to male counterparts and until we start to express our discontent at contorting not only our physical bodies, but our emotional and spiritual ones as well, to fit into this world created by men, for men, we will not be fully liberated or fully valued on our own terms.



6 comments:

Anonymous said...

I don't think you get the actual meaning behind the song. It's more about not feeling like you have to be skinny to be desirable. While yes, it would be nice to be attracted to someone based on their mind and personality let's face it. Neither you nor I look at someone and go "Oh, he is so smart, look at his I.Q. score!"
This song is more an anthem to bigger girls out there to show that they have just as much (if not more) to offer than all the "skinny bitches" out there.
Before you tear down a song look more into it before jumping up and down stating it's sexist. Maybe you should look more into Nicki Minaj's Anaconda or even J.Lo's Booty. You might get further in your rant.

Anne said...

I think it'd be great to talk further about this and how you feel the song empowers you. However, your comment is listed as anonymous. I think it'd be great if you owned your voice so that we could talk further.

Jill said...

This a forum where everyone can share their opinion without fear of reprisal and judgment. Words and phrases such as "skinny bitches,""jumping up and down," and other statements that belie a defensive character and contain a cruel undertone do not support or promote the idea that all women have a voice that should be respected and heard. Instead, such comments, unfortunately pit women against each other in a competition that only harms our gender further. Anonymous, you and I will have to agree to disagree on this one because I think the poster intended to make the point that you should feel good about yourself regardless of your size and physical stature without male approval. However, despite disagreement with your comment, I do hope you will share your name as this blog and it's readers should all be confident speaking with their own voice.

Ms Molly: said...

Amy: I like your post, but I think what's really sad is that too many people (young & old) look to entertainers (including athletes) as role models. We need to teach our kids that entertainment is just entertainment. It's nothing new that songs are controversial. It's what sells. Do I think it's all about that bass? or a size 2? Nope. Do I feel empowered by it? Definitely not. Am I entertained by it? Yes, and admittedly, I think it's a catchy song, and it's on my playlist. If I got rid of every song containing a negative social theme, it would be a pretty short play list.

Off topic but kind of related: We've been discussing mainstream "rapey" songs at work. (Jill used to work with me so she could explain why this would be a topic of conversation.) Blurred Lines started the conversation, and we thought of Garth Brooks' That Summer; Deana Carter's Strawberry Wine; and Cher's Gypsies, Tramps and Thieves--all statutory rape songs and all pretty popular in their time. Would they be if released today? I hope not, but Blurred Lines probably confirms they would be. (Here's where I admit Blurred Lines is on my playlist too. I'm part of the problem, but I just can't resist a catchy song!)

Keep blogging ladies! I'm enjoying your opinions.

Tabetha said...

Dear anonymous:
http://jennytrout.com/?p=7857
Here is a very good dissection of this song. While it's a catchy tune and I wish it offered its potential, it is not the anthem it could have been. The lyrics, sadly, paint the picture as Amy points out, of a woman's worth being tied to her desirability by men. And backhanded comments of skinny women does not send the message to love yourself no matter your size. I am sorry, I do not agree that this song has a good meaning. I think it is you who really needs to take a second look at it. But, if it has helped you in some way, I guess you won't be swayed by our opinions.

StephCreative said...

Totally agree with this post. And I hate the way this song pits women against women. If you're not curvalicious, you're a "skinny bitch." And if you're thin, then you're obviously obsessed with appearances and shallow, and men won't like you anyway because you don't have enough booty to hold on to.

Competing for male attention is old. Sure, physical appearances might get you noticed, but it's PERSONALITY that makes people want to spend time with you. Having "all the right junk in all the right places" is great for a sexual encounter, but relationships are more than sexual encounters.

Also, how degrading is this song to men? As if all men want is arm candy. They just sit around waiting for women to bend themselves to the accepted social stereotype of outward beauty, and then pick one, cuz they're all the same. News flash: not all men are shallow jerks. Some men want the same things women claim to want in a mate. Things like a sense of humor, integrity, loyalty, spontenaity, confidence, intelligence and kindness.

And maybe when women stop trying to "attract male attention," they'll find men (and other women, and just PEOPLE in general) who love and appreciate them for who they are inside.

And lastly, the god-awful pastel cardigans in that music video are so demeaning, and clearly aimed at appealing to very young girls. The media keeps reaching for younger and younger dollars, and it's just sad.

Featured Post

Meaning-Making

I’m almost 38 years old. Here’s what I’ve learned and experienced about life as I age. The older I get, the more intensely I feel things. ...